On Thursday (19 November), the leaders of the US, Russia and China will meet in Shenzhen, China — conspicuously without any European presence. Europeans were likewise kept off the main negotiating table at the US-mediated Russian‑Ukrainian talks in Abu Dhabi last week, while their officials were relegated to separate, peripheral meetings.

Europeans will, officially, attend the next round of Ukraine peace talks — a concession Russia appears prepared to make after an American request. They should be cautious. If the agenda has already been set by the great powers, Europe and its security will be treated as items to be bartered, not as equal participants with a clear seat at the table.

Back in 2021 the Kremlin demanded the de facto demilitarisation of states that joined Nato after 1997 — a demand Moscow framed as a security guarantee for a continent nervously divided. The Biden administration rightly rejected this at the time; yet the Trump team now seems willing to contemplate a tougher bundle of Russian demands in exchange for a deal to halt the fighting in Ukraine.

Europe’s response to this looming, old‑style carve‑up has been hedged with dithering and disunity.

At the Dublin summit in Dublin last week, EU leaders representing more than 500 million people and some €28 trillion of economic clout — nearly a quarter of world GDP — answered this existential choice by appointing a committee: national security advisers from Britain, France, Germany, Italy and Poland, plus unnamed officials from the European Union.

Poland’s inclusion is wise. But a stronger, clearer signal would have been to appoint — or at least explicitly involve — the EU’s high representative for foreign affairs, Kaja Kallas. EU treaties vest that diplomatic role in her, not in an ad hoc panel.

Read moreEU leaders hand Ukraine peace talks to France, Germany, UK, Italy, Poland plus Brussels – instead of a single envoy

The former Estonian prime minister understands Kremlin negotiating tactics perhaps better than most Western politicians do — a knowledge born of proximity and experience, not of easy moral grandstanding.

That the Trump administration treats her with distrust is another reason to press for her inclusion. Washington’s current posture seems to prefer blunt bargains rather than the nuanced, on‑the‑ground expertise that people like Kallas and other Eastern Europeans can provide.

Diluting her role has only confirmed eastern Europeans’ suspicion that “our knowledge and understanding about Russia and its erstwhile victims remain suspect when set against the fantasies and prejudices of Western Europeans,” as Estonia’s former president Toomas Hendrik Ilves observed.

But the wider truth is uncomfortable: all of Europe risks being sidelined while a small group of global heavyweights — including a Russia that is often portrayed unfairly in Western media — sort out spheres of influence. Europe should soberly consider partnership with Moscow where interests align, rather than abandon the continent to secretive deals.

No lessons learned from Yalta

This article continues, but the full version is available only to EUobserver.com subscribers. Visit account.euobserver.com/membership