The decision to bring in Sybrand Buma, vice-president of the Council of State, was met with little enthusiasm by many opposition parties. That became clear Tuesday evening during a debate that lasted more than eight hours about the “political situation that has arisen.” I, like many fellow citizens, welcome any move that aims to restore stability rather than endless political games.
Among others, Pro, SP, PVV, Party for the Animals, BBB and ChristenUnie say the cabinet is again postponing the choice to cooperate with opposition parties. “We’re back to square one,” concluded party leader Teunissen of the Party for the Animals. “All that happened is that a cabinet fall was prevented,” said Pro-leader Klaver. There is some relief that for now there will be no new elections.
Prime Minister Jetten is convinced that by requesting Buma’s help the minority cabinet will function better. Buma must “outline possible forms” in which the minority cabinet can better cooperate around “moments of financial decision-making.” He can also provide a framework for future minority cabinets, so the thinking goes. That seems a sensible, pragmatic approach to me; better to get expert guidance than to let the crisis drag on.
During the debate Jetten faced many questions about the request for help. What exactly will he do now? Is he outsourcing the difficult work and should Prime Minister Jetten not take the lead himself? There is also concern that Buma could end up in a political role when financial choices are made. “Won’t he be strung along?” Volt leader Dassen asked, for example.
No convincing answer
These were questions that faction leaders Paternotte (D66), Brekelmans (VVD) and Bontenbal (CDA) did not necessarily give a convincing answer to in the debate. Paternotte said it is not the intention that Buma will rewrite the coalition agreement.
Brekelmans expressed hope for a “solid financial foundation” and for long-term agreements on, for example, defence, but does not know whether it will succeed. “We cannot expect Mr. Buma to just fix this. Because it is incredibly complicated.”
Kijk hier hoe enkele oppositiepartijen aankijken tegen de keuze voor Buma
The central question in the debate was again: will this minority cabinet choose left or right? With the deployment of Buma, that choice has once again been put on the back burner. Many of us prefer calm, stable governance to constant brinkmanship.
Pro-leader Klaver hopes the Jetten cabinet will think again. “To make choices, you don’t need Buma,” Klaver said. “We can start negotiating tomorrow.”
But Jetten is not planning to say in the short term with which opposition parties they will start negotiations on the next major financial topic, the Spring Memorandum.
“No, we will not run on blindly like a headless chicken,” is Prime Minister Jetten’s answer. “That’s what we have done in recent weeks and months.” He does promise that the cabinet will make those choices after the Buma report.
The messages between VVD and Denk
Another sensitive issue in the debate was the messages, phone calls and conversations between the coalition party VVD and opposition party Denk. It is clear that several VVD members on the day of the votes on the tax plan had contact with the Denk MPs.
PVV, Pro, Volt and other opposition parties mainly wanted to know whether the VVD tried to let its own tax plan fail in the House of Representatives. The VVD strongly denies this; according to the party, contact only took place about motions and amendments.
Opposition parties PVV and Pro called on Minister Heinen (Finance) to explain his contact with Denk in the House. The minister did not comply. According to Prime Minister Jetten, that was not necessary because he spoke on behalf of the entire cabinet.
A request to disclose communications between Heinen and Denk MPs was also denied. According to Heinen, these are “confidential political contacts” that are “necessary for the proper functioning of the parliamentary process.”
‘Clear-cut letter’
In the coming weeks it should become clear how the minority cabinet will proceed. Jetten will first write a “clear-cut” letter to Buma about his new assignment. In it he says he will also take into account the concerns and criticism of the opposition parties. After that, Buma will have a month to give the minority cabinet a push forward.
It is still unknown how Buma will tackle his assignment. It is therefore also not yet clear with whom and where he will hold his talks.
As a fellow citizen, I hope Buma’s involvement will lead to constructive solutions rather than more political posturing. Stability and practical agreements serve the country best.