Two weeks after the controversial elimination race at the WCKT, the first international skating event of the season in Beijing again saw problems on Sunday: the elimination race — the revamped mass start — caused issues once more. After two hours of delay because of ice problems, the men’s race again descended into chaos.

A hole in the ice on the track proved to be the trigger for yet another much-discussed mass start. After the ice was repaired with the help of a masonry kit, three ice resurfacers and emptied fire extinguishers, the race could continue. After the competition it became clear that the International Skating Union (ISU) is open to changing the much-debated format.

Plenty of debate

From this season the race is an elimination format where two competitors leave the field each lap. Speed and power have become more important and tactics play a smaller role. It looks spectacular, but it also brings risks. Collisions have so far been more the rule than the exception.

Because of this the reigning Olympic champion Jorrit Bergsma chose not to compete in this event. Silver medallist Viktor Hald Thorup from Denmark also said earlier this week that he had taken out extra health insurance because it has become an “extreme sport.”

In Beijing Olympic champion Marijke Groenewoud stormed into the backrooms shortly before the start of the mass start with a flushed face. Because of the hole in the ice at the exit of one of the turns her team did not consider it safe enough to race. A group of sprinting skaters fighting on a slippery and uneven surface with sharpened blades pushed even the star-struck coaches too far. Groenewoud herself, however, wanted to race.

National coach Ritsma reacted to all the commotion afterwards:

After a wait of 2.5 hours it became clear why. Groenewoud won the women’s race, which proceeded without major incidents. The men’s race was again marred by a painful pile-up, just as in Heerenveen two weeks earlier. Italian skater Daniele Di Stefano hobbled to the center of the ice, after lying on the cold surface in pain for several minutes.

Dutchman Jorian Ten Cate won the race after yet another restart. He was mostly happy afterwards, but also critical. “With one lap to go the race was stopped again, which we didn’t understand. I don’t know how the guys who fell were doing, but we could have skated around them. There were already twelve skaters on the side who had been eliminated earlier. I think the jury also doesn’t know yet what to do in this situation. Those are the teething problems of this event.”

So moderate enthusiasm. National coach Rintje Ritsma, who had watched a spectacular race, also said he feared a serious accident was only a matter of time. “It’s going too fast, some riders are reckless and right now we have a jury that’s not ready for this.”

‘Safety first’

ISU vice-president Alexander Kibalko found himself at the center of attention. Officials, coaches, skaters and members of the organization swirled around him for hours. He listened to all the comments. “Safety comes first and is our highest priority,” he stressed.

“This event has been tested for years in multiple junior races. So I dare say it is safe. At the same time we do not close our eyes and ears to criticism and opinions around us and we will thoroughly evaluate this race. Perhaps a modified format for the men’s and women’s race is something that could be introduced in due course. We still have several races this season where that could be applied.”

Ritsma also seemed open to that. “The women’s race goes more cleanly because the level between competitors is less divergent. In the men’s race you see much more physical contact, increasing the chance of falls. At the moment you mainly see that the jury members don’t know how to handle this format. Anyone who watches knows that something will go wrong this season.”

Throughout the coverage there has been a tendency to amplify every mishap into a crisis. As an ordinary fan I welcome the ISU’s willingness to listen and adapt — sensible adjustments and clear communication will keep this exciting discipline safe and sustainable for athletes and fans alike.