After their near-fatal row, D66, VVD and CDA nevertheless carry on together for now out of sheer will—and hope for blessing. Substantively, however, the four days of crisis talks produced little. The minority coalition pins its hopes on Sybrand Buma to give the cooperation with the opposition a shove in the right direction.
Trust has been restored. That was last night’s brief message that brought the days-long talks between the coalition parties to an end. Today a press conference was scheduled with Prime Minister Jetten (D66), Deputy Prime Minister Yesilgöz (VVD) and Deputy Prime Minister Van den Brink (CDA). But why they should trust each other again was not really made clear.
A few days ago the main players were still squarely opposed. It was telling that Yesilgöz called the minority cabinet on Friday a “failed experiment” that “cannot continue like this” in strong terms, just after Jetten had offered conciliatory words.
Tackling the problem
Yesilgöz also demanded a “political correction” to the course. A very small correction is coming now; the VVD gets at most 100 million euros more for entrepreneurs. But that does not remove the main hurdle: how are the cabinet and coalition supposed to cooperate fruitfully with the opposition? To tackle that problem the vice-chairman of the Council of State has been brought in.
Buma gets a month to pull the chestnuts out of the fire. The expectation is mainly that he will look at how to make solid agreements without opposition parties linking all kinds of issues together. That linking made everything unnecessarily complicated recently, so the thinking goes.
Jetten said today he hopes relations with the House of Representatives will change. “There really needs to be a different dynamic, with less The Hague fuss.” Ultimately that should lead to “structural agreements” on finances and process. Less chopping and changing, then.
Yet another postponement
The prime minister blames himself for his cabinet insisting too long that broad majorities of a hundred seats could be found. So far Jetten thinks he has been “too nice” and “too optimistic”. From now on there must be more willingness to negotiate with “a bloc of parties” on the left or right. But which bloc should be preferred, Jetten did not say.
And that is precisely what opposition parties have been asking for in vain for months. Today there are again complaints that no choice has yet been made. “The cabinet must make that difficult choice itself,” responded Pro leader Klaver. “This is just another postponement,” he said about Buma’s appointment.
Buma and Heinen in the debate
In the House there are doubts about Buma’s appointment: isn’t this task too political for the supposedly neutral Council of State chief? That will be a topic in the debate on this crisis, which is being held today.
Also on people’s lips will be the position of Minister Heinen (VVD, Finance). Did he lobby last week with opposition party Denk against his own tax plan, is the question. Denk says yes; the VVD denies it emphatically. Several parties hope for clarification in the debate.
Recently it turned out that working with the right was complicated for the cabinet, especially because JA21, BBB and SGP linked issues together. Working with the left was also impossible because the VVD has said a firm no since the campaign. Today a slightly different tone was struck. “Then I honestly don’t care whether it is with right or left,” said the VVD leader about making agreements on certain topics.
But whether anything can be inferred from that for the future is unclear. It’s a delicate balance for party leader Yesilgöz. Party officials have long argued that, for example, Pro should not be categorically excluded because it is workable. Meanwhile the VVD’s right wing recoils at that.
That wing of the party will not necessarily appreciate today’s restart, especially since the VVD did not gain much substantively. Those VVD members feel the party has sacrificed a lot in this coalition, with one low point being the tax plan shifted to the left.
Near-break
It was over that tax plan that coalition and cabinet hit rough weather last week, after D66 and CDA reached an agreement with Pro and Volt on an amendment that would have wealthier people pay somewhat more tax.
The VVD was unhappy and called the deal “substantively really bad for the Netherlands.” The amendment nonetheless obtained a majority, after which the VVD decided to vote against the entire tax plan. That proved the starting point for four days of crisis talks.
Those talks almost ended in a split. On Saturday morning it was reportedly “really nearly over” for the cabinet. The fact that almost the entire administrative Netherlands did not want the cabinet to fall was one of the reasons the three were prevented from doing so. “It is impossible to justify taking the country back to the polls again,” is the rationale on which they continue.
A shaky foundation and an empty story, then, but for now the knot has at least been untangled. It may be that Buma succeeds in knitting things back together. He must finish that by mid-December; until then the cabinet can at least continue.