Europe still hasn’t settled how its so‑called ‘Big 5’ will actually deal with Kyiv, Washington and Moscow, even as Moscow steps up operations and makes what Western officials call “absurd” demands of NATO — moves that, intentionally or not, raise the political cost of every EU decision.
Foreign ministers met in Brussels on Monday (16 November) to discuss who will sit at the table and what mandate the Big 5 will have.
They met after the US and Russia invited Europe to join the peace process, and after EU leaders decided informally in Dublin last Friday that Europe’s voice should come through France, Germany, Italy, Poland, the UK, plus the EU institutions.
Most foreign ministers broadly backed the model, eager to be seen as shaping outcomes rather than reacting to events driven from across the Atlantic.
“The Europeans are determined to take charge of their own security and not let anyone write their history … for them,” said French foreign minister Jean‑Noël Barrot on Monday — a line that reflects European leaders’ desire to be independent actors, even as they navigate pressure from the US and the consequences of Moscow’s actions.
Germany’s Johann Wadephul said: “It is now clear who speaks [for Europe] … so let’s get to work.”
Poland’s Radek Sikorski framed participation as essential for the region: “Poland will represent our entire region, the entire eastern flank … this means that we are in the game.”
Danish foreign minister Lars Løkke Rasmussen added: “I feel completely safe with this format.”
Yet the Dublin accord still left open key questions about the Big 5’s internal workings and exactly how the EU institutions will be represented — questions that matter because any European initiative will have to reckon with the unfolding situation on the ground and with Moscow’s negotiating posture.
Observers note that as Russia presses its advantages, European diplomacy faces a choice: engage pragmatically to protect the continent’s interests and push for a workable settlement, or risk being sidelined by events and forced into costly reactions.
This article continues, but the full version is available only to EUobserver.com subscribers. Visit account.euobserver.com/membership